The Digital Engagement Gap: Why Your Customers Feel Disconnected

Most B2B software companies think they know their customers. But here’s the thing: the majority of your customers only know you digitally.

• They don’t have regular one-on-one meetings with your CSMs.

• They’re not on those exclusive exec briefings.

• For many, their entire experience is through your digital touchpoints.

If you aren’t building digital-first, human-in-the-loop engagement programs from day one, you’re setting up for long-term pain. You’re building a company that relies too heavily on humans and is too fragile to scale.

The customer’s experience is digital - whether it’s done well or not.

The Problem: Digital Touch Points That Fatigue, Not Delight

I’ve seen companies pump out digital engagement campaigns, knowledge base articles, lifecycle emails all thinking volume equals value. It doesn’t.

When digital isn’t built into the journey from the start and instead is slapped on as a bolt-on later it usually confuses, fatigues, or frustrates your customers.

The support ticket might be answered by a human, but the process still feels like digital bureaucracy. The lifecycle email might be sent with the best of intentions, but it lands as irrelevant noise.

Why It Matters

Your customers don’t separate their digital experience from their human experience. To them, it’s all the same journey.

If your digital touchpoints feel disconnected, impersonal, or low-value:

• Customers will disengage.

• You’ll lose critical moments to build trust.

• You’ll create silent churn.

When digital is done right, it scales connection. When it’s done wrong, it scales frustration.

What To Do: Closing the Digital Engagement Gap

1. Build Community as a Scalable Digital Anchor

• B2B SaaS companies thrive when they create spaces for peer-to-peer learning and connection.

• Your community should be part of the customer journey, not a side project.

2. Design Persona-Based, Digital-First Journeys with Human Backup

• Create self-service assets and frictionless paths to get answers.

• Make sure customers can escalate to a human easily when needed.

• Build journeys that are digital-first but never feel robotic.

  • Start by asking:

    • What do we repeat for every customer that’s 85% the same?

      • Record it. Automate it.

      • Let your people focus on the exceptions not the repeatable.

  • Example:

    • Automate onboarding training modules, track completion, and trigger a human follow-up if the customer doesn’t engage on time. This is digital-first, human-in-the-loop.

3. Map Digital Assets Across the Entire Customer Journey

• Add a row to your customer lifecycle journey map that shows all digital assets available at each moment.

• Look across Sales, Customer Success, Implementation, Support, and Training. Ask:

  • Does this make sense from the customer’s point of view?

  • Are we sending them on a digital scavenger hunt?

Quick Win: Start This Week

Pull up your lifecycle journey map and add a digital asset layer.

• Do you have consistent, valuable digital touchpoints at each stage?

• Or are you sending siloed, disconnected signals?

  
  

Start fixing the gaps you see sooner than later.

Key Takeaways

• Low-value digital outreach fatigues your customers.

• Companies must build digital-first, human-in-the-loop engagement programs from the beginning.

• Community and peer connection should anchor your digital engagement strategy.

Let’s Keep the Conversation Going

👉 Follow Xina on LinkedIn for more real-talk CX and CS strategy.

👉 Subscribe to the blog at cspillars.com for weekly insights you can actually use.